The State Bar of Texas Construction Law Section
search
email
Home Members Section Newsletters Conferences Neutrals resources
  Featured Article  



Full Text
Adobe PDF Format


Download
WordPerfect
format

Need help downloading?



NOT-SO-MUDDY WATERS
STORMWATER UPDATE
1998 CONSTRUCTION GENERAL PERMIT

12th Annual Construction Law Conference

February 25 & 26, 1999

Dallas, Texas

Janet McQuaid(1)

Fulbright & Jaworski L.L.P.
600 Congress Ave., Suite 2400
Austin, Texas 78701
(512) 322-2429


Table of Contents

LIST OF ATTACHMENTS
  1. Background
  2. Scope
    1. Discharges Covered
    2. Persons Covered
    3. Activities Covered
    4. Common Plan of Development
  3. Control Requirements
    1. Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan
      1. Content
      2. Persons Responsible
      3. Operator and Contractor Certifications
      4. Certifications under the Endangered Species Act
      5. Public Access to Plan Document
    2. Permittee Inspections
    3. Final Stabilization and Termination
    4. Record Retention
  4. Penalties for Noncompliance
    1. Administrative Penalties
      1. Class I Penalties ($11,000 per violation; $27,500 total)
      2. Class II ($11,000 per violation per day; $137,500 total)
    2. Civil Penalties ($27,500 per day per violation)
    3. Criminal Penalties ($25,000 to $1,000,000 plus imprisonment)
    4. False Statements ($10,000 plus imprisonment)
  5. Compliance Strategies
    1. Before Construction Commences
    2. During Construction
    3. During an EPA Inspection
    4. After an EPA Inspection
  6. Summary

Notes

Abstract

In 1987, Congress amended the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, commonly referred to as the Clean Water Act, to require the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to establish a permitting program for storm water discharges into waters of the United States. The EPA promulgated the first stormwater regulations on November 16, 1990. These regulations set permitting and compliance requirements for "stormwater discharges associated with industrial activities," as that phrase is defined in the regulations. Construction activities are included among the activities defined as industrial activities and, therefore, are subject to the stormwater discharge permitting and compliance requirements.

Facilities that meet the definition of "stormwater discharge associated with construction activity" are required to apply for NPDES permit coverage. Construction activities have two permitting methods available to them. The first and by far the most common method of obtaining a permit for discharges from construction activities is to apply for coverage under the 1998 Construction Permit. This permit was finalized by the EPA for Region VI by publication in the Federal Register on July 6, 1998, and it expires at midnight on July 6, 2003. The other method of obtaining a permit for discharges from construction activities, and by far the less commonly utilized, is to apply for either an individual NPDES permit or an alternative NPDES general permit. These types of permits involve a much more comprehensive approval process, including public notice and opportunity to comment, and are used primarily in cases where it is determined that the general Construction Permit is not sufficient (for example, where there will be discharges other than those permitted by the Construction Permit).

A good source for information about the Construction Permit and EPA contacts in Region 6 are the EPA Region 6 stormwater sites on the Worldwide Web, at the following addresses:

http://www.epa.gov/earth1r6/6wq/npdes(water quality division);

http://www.epa.gov/earth1r6/6en/w/sw (enforcement division).

Forms, instructions, and other material about the Construction Permit are available at these web sites. Materials not available on the stormwater web sites may often be obtained by calling the following numbers:

Stormwater Hotline: (800) 245-6510;

EPA Documents: (202) 260-7786.

The EPA has delegated authority to environmental authorities in Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, and Texas to implement the general permit program on behalf of the EPA. The rules and regulations of the Arkansas Department of Pollution Control and Ecology (501/682-0627), the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality (504/765-0525), and the Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality (405/271-7440 x118) should be consulted with respect to projects in those states. New Mexico has not assumed the NPDES storm water program and the EPA directly implements the NPDES program within the state. However, the New Mexico Environment Department does have staff to handle storm water issues (505/827-2798). Texas only recently has obtained delegated authority for the NPDES stormwater programs, and the EPA will continue to implement the program during the term of the 1998 Construction Permit, as discussed in more detail below. The balance of this paper will focus on the EPA's implementation of the NPDES stormwater program for construction activities in Texas.

Texas assumed the authority to administer the NPDES program in Texas on September 14, 1998. As part of this program, known as the TPDES in Texas, the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission (TNRCC) received federal regulatory power over discharges of storm water associated with industrial activity (including construction sites) and discharges of storm water from municipal separate storm sewer systems (MS4s). Thus, the TNRCC TPDES program now covers all permitting, surveillance, inspection, public assistance, and enforcement regulatory processes associated with storm water discharges from those sources. Discharges of storm water associated with oil, gas, and geothermal exploration and development activities, however, will continue to be regulated by the Railroad Commission of Texas.

The transition from EPA administration of the NPDES program to TNRCC administration of the TPDES program will not be immediate. The EPA is temporarily maintaining permitting, surveillance, and enforcement jurisdiction over individual and general NPDES permits proposed for public comment but not yet final at the time of program assumption by the TNRCC. The EPA will administer these permits until such time as EPA-promulgated permits expire and the TNRCC adopts new permits to replace them. For the 1998 Construction Permit, this means that EPA will continue to receive NOIs and enforce the permit until July 6, 2003. The EPA is also retaining administration over large and medium MS4 permits issued prior to Texas program assumption and over EPA-issued construction and multi-sector industrial storm water general permits until the existing permits expire. As a result, applications for general permits under the 1998 Construction Permit must still be made to the EPA.

In summary, as with any regulatory program, the best defense against the EPA's "men in black" is to prepare and maintain the notices, plans and records required by the Construction Permit before an inspection ever occurs. The EPA is authorized under the Clean Water Act to enter and inspect a construction site. It is advisable for a person knowledgeable in erosion and sedimentation control and the provisions of the SWPPP and Construction Permit to accompany the EPA inspector. A representative of the EPA should not, however, be unduly delayed or denied access to the site if, for example, a knowledgeable person is not reasonably available to accompany the inspector.

If an EPA inspection unfortunately reveals real or perceived violations, prompt correction (during the EPA's inspection, if possible) may help mitigate the potential penalty. If an Administrative Order is forthcoming, an enforcement conference is usually advisable to clarify the facts underlying a violation and possibly help to eliminate some violations. If an Administrative Complaint proposing a Class I (up to $27,500) penalty is forthcoming, it is often possible to negotiate an agreed penalty and Consent Order, and an extension of time to do so should be requested. If an Administrative Complaint proposing Class II (up to $137,500) penalty is proposed, the Complaint should be answered. Settlement discussions or preparation for hearing, or both, may then ensue.


Full Text Adobe PDF Format

LIST OF ATTACHMENTS

  1. 1998 Construction General Permit Notice of Intent (NOI)

  2. 1998 Construction General Permit Notice of Termination (NOT)

  3. EPA Region 6 NPDES Storm Water Construction SWPPP Certification

  4. EPA NPDES Construction Inspection Form

  5. Example Site Map

  6. 1998 NPDES General Construction Storm Water Permit Checklist

You must have the free Adobe Acrobat Reader 4.0 (or greater) installed in your computer in order to view or print these appendices. It is available as a free download from the Adobe Web site. If you do not have Acrobat Reader installed, click the link to the left to download it. If a menu window opens before the paper, choose the "View" option.




home | members | section | newsletters | conferences | neutrals | resources
search | what's new | email


Questions or Comments? Give us feedback.
© 1998-2004 The State Bar of Texas Construction Law Section


Problems with the site?
Contact  webmaster@constlaw.org


Last updated 2 June 2001